Children and adults across 15 countries believe in human uniqueness of mind: a cross-cultural investigation of cross-species mind perception

Neldner K, Maurits L, Junker M, Abbas L, Abbas N, Abis A, Amici F, Arroyo-Garcia B, Asghari N, Pardo GB, Zhang Z, Chumacero JP, Dzabatou A, Eirdosh D, Hanisch S, Herrnsdorf T, Hovehne T, Junker A, Kanngiesser P, Larens FV, Mahmoud S, Masaquiza S, Masato I, Maulany RI, Meng T, Mutlu K, Ngakan PO, Peközer E, Petrović L, Rehatalanit MC, Piscayanti KS, Pope-Caldwell S, Sandoval Sernaque MI, Shishala D, Sportelli D, Stengelin R, Stodulka T, Striegler B, Sun W, Sunderarajan J, Tempelmann S, Thajib F, Thiede N, Tjizao D, Useb L, Woidich L, Weyrowitz J, Haun D, Liebal K (2026)

Publication Type: Journal article

Publication year: 2026

Journal

Journal of Environmental Psychology Elsevier

Book Volume: 109

Article Number: 102861

DOI: 10.1016/j.jenvp.2025.102861

Abstract

The way humans relate to other animals is fundamentally shaped by whether we perceive ourselves as unique, with feelings and thoughts not shared by other animals. How beliefs about animals’ ability to feel and think develop across cultures remains largely unexplored. We asked children and adolescents (4–17 years, N = 1025) and adults (N = 190) from 33 urban and rural communities across 15 countries whether animals have thoughts or feelings (judgments of presence), and whether those thoughts or feelings are human-like (judgments of similarity). Bayesian analyses revealed that participants generally ascribed non-human animals the ability for thoughts and feelings. However, they universally denied that animals have human-like thoughts, with these beliefs emerging early in development across all societies and remaining stable across the lifespan. There was more cultural variation found in whether participants attributed human-like feelings to animals. Human mental exceptionalism appears to be a human universal and is restricted to human-like thoughts. Implications for human-animal relationships and ethical considerations for the treatment and conservation of other animals are discussed.

Authors with CRIS profile

Teuku Ferdiansyah Thajib Standards of Decision-Making Across Cultures (SDAC) - Knowledge, Authenticity, Time

Involved external institutions

Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology / Max-Planck-Institut für evolutionäre Anthropologie DE Germany (DE) Chinese Academy of Sciences (CAS) / 中国科学院 CN China (CN) University of Plymouth GB United Kingdom (GB) Westfälische Wilhelms-Universität (WWU) Münster DE Germany (DE) Universität Leipzig DE Germany (DE) Pädagogische Hochschule Bern (PHBern) CH Switzerland (CH) Universitas Pendidikan Ganesha ID Indonesia (ID)

How to cite

APA:

Neldner, K., Maurits, L., Junker, M., Abbas, L., Abbas, N., Abis, A.,... Liebal, K. (2026). Children and adults across 15 countries believe in human uniqueness of mind: a cross-cultural investigation of cross-species mind perception. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 109. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2025.102861

MLA:

Neldner, Karri, et al. "Children and adults across 15 countries believe in human uniqueness of mind: a cross-cultural investigation of cross-species mind perception." Journal of Environmental Psychology 109 (2026).

BibTeX: Download