Reply to discussion by RN Scoon and AA Mitchell on 'Oxygen isotope and trace element compositions of platiniferous dunite pipes of the Bushveld Complex, South Africa - Signals from a recycled mantle component?' (2019) Günther T, Haase K, Junge M, Oberthuer T, Wölki D, Krumm S Journal article, Letter Age constraints on high-pressure/low-temperature metamorphism and sedimentation in the Luk Ulo Complex (Java, Indonesia) (2019) Hoffmann J, Broecker M, Setiawan N, Klemd R, Berndt J, Maulana A, Baier H Journal article Geochronology and Zr-in-rutile thermometry of high-pressure/low temperature metamorphic rocks from the Bantimala complex, SW Sulawesi, Indonesia (2019) Boehnke M, Broecker M, Maulana A, Klemd R, Berndt J, Baier H Journal article Zircon trace element constrains on the link between volcanism and plutonism in SE-China (2018) Yan LL, He Z, Beier C, Klemd R Journal article Oxygen isotope and trace element compositions of platiniferous dunite pipes of the Bushveld Complex, South Africa - Signals from a recycled mantle component? (2018) Günther T, Haase K, Junge M, Oberthür T, Wölki D, Krumm S Journal article, Original article Oxygen isotope and trace element compositions of platiniferous dunite pipes of the Bushveld Complex, South Africa – Signals from a recycled mantle component? (2018) Günther T, Haase K, Junge M, Oberthür T, Wölki D, Krumm S Journal article Geochemical evidence for Paleozoic crustal growth and tectonic conversion in the Northern Beishan Orogenic Belt, southern Central Asian Orogenic Belt (2018) Yuan Y, Zong K, He Z, Klemd R, Jiang H, Zhang W, Liu Y, et al. Journal article Rare peak and ubiquitous post-peak zircon in eclogite: Constraints for the timing of UHP and HP metamorphism in Erzgebirge, Germany (2018) Schmädicke E, Will TM, Ling X, Li XH, Li QL Journal article, Original article New evidence for an old idea: Geochronological constraints for a paired metamorphic belt in the central European Variscides (2018) Will TM, Schmädicke E, Ling XX, Li XH, Li QL Journal article, Original article Tectonic control on the genesis of magmas in the New Hebrides arc (Vanuatu) (2018) Beier C, Brandl P, Martins Lima SS, Haase K Journal article, Original article