Gelius P, Messing S, Abu-Omar K (2019)
Publication Type: Journal article, Original article
Publication year: 2019
Book Volume: 77
Journal Issue: 1
DOI: 10.1186/s13690-019-0381-x
Background The field of physical activity abounds with recommendations, guidelines, action plans and other documents published by experts, organizations and institutions at the national and international level. However, working with these documents is difficult since similar names (e.g. "recommendations") may be used to label substantially different contents, while identical topics may hide behind different monikers (e.g. "guidelines" and "strategy"). Methods We built on an existing framework conceptualizing categories of physical activity evidence and on the Doern continuum for policy instruments to develop a nine-field matrix that classifies physical activity-related publications based on their evidence type and degree of coercion. We used a selection of eleven physical activity documents to perform an exploratory test of the functions and utility of the typology. Results Placing central physical activity documents into the typology shows that recommendations, guidelines, and policies are found across the entire matrix, regardless of their denomination. It also suggests that some documents transcend boundaries between types by falling into more than one category, and that some categories may be underrepresented in current physical activity promotion. Conclusions A typology to classify physical activity guidelines, recommendations, and policies can help us acquire a better overview of the landscape of existing physical activity documents than simple distinctions based on document names. It may guide both current initiatives and future development work in the field. It could also serve as a point of departure for future research, as conducting systematic overviews of the literature based on this typology may help reveal important gaps in current physical activity promotion.
APA:
Gelius, P., Messing, S., & Abu-Omar, K. (2019). Nine types of recommendations, guidelines and policies: an exploratory test of a proposed typology of physical activity promotion documents. Archives of Public Health, 77(1). https://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13690-019-0381-x
MLA:
Gelius, Peter, Sven Messing, and Karim Abu-Omar. "Nine types of recommendations, guidelines and policies: an exploratory test of a proposed typology of physical activity promotion documents." Archives of Public Health 77.1 (2019).
BibTeX: Download